Skip to Content

Moving To LGBTQ Staten Island, New York? How To Find Your Perfect Gay Neighborhood!

Moving To LGBTQ Staten Island, New York? How To Find Your Perfect Gay Neighborhood!

Sweethearts, let’s talk about a hidden jewel for the LGBTQ+ community – the peaceful and picturesque Staten Island. You may know it as the ‘forgotten borough,’ but honey, it’s time to remember it for its alluring charm, lush green spaces, and serene beaches.

Only a ferry ride away from Manhattan, Staten Island is a conservative gem with a heart as big as its history!

Dive into a place where love, acceptance, and pride come together. Staten Island is more than a place to live; it’s a queer oasis that opens its arms wide to those in search of an inclusive and welcoming atmosphere. Considering LGBTQ+ Staten Island for your next home? Darling, you’re on the brink of finding the perfect, embracing niche that you and your loved ones have been yearning for.

Think of Staten Island as a gentle embrace in the bustling dance of New York City. Its local queer scene might not be as loud as the big city, but it shines with a distinct pride all its own. It’s a quieter treasure that reflects the embracing corners of cities like Jersey City, Philadelphia, Baltimore, or Providence, yet stands as a calm counterpoint to the vibrant energy of Brooklyn or Queens.

Now, precious, let a gay realtor in Staten Island be your guide. They’re your glittering key to unlocking a dream home in the most welcoming gayborhood tailored just for you. Trust in their wisdom, and they’ll lead you to a spot where you can flourish.

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island
Gay Real Estate USA

Feeling hesitant about Staten Island’s subtler queer culture? Let me reassure you, dear; the rainbow flag doesn’t just fly here – it flutters with elegance and grace. Staten Island’s residents are a diverse and welcoming tapestry, eager to include you in their rich community. From boutique shopping to those cozy cafés, you’ll feel a pride that resonates with every welcoming smile.

Together, we’ll explore the treasures that await you in LGBTQ+ Staten Island. Whether you’re making this adventure alone or bringing your family along, we’ll set a smooth course for you to slip effortlessly into your fresh, splendid life. Let a gay realtor in Staten Island equip you with all you need to dive into this unique adventure!

So, brush aside those misconceptions, dearest, and let Staten Island entice you with its tranquil beauty. With the serenity of a small town and the spirit of a big city, Staten Island offers something you didn’t know you needed. A move to LGBTQ+ Staten Island isn’t just a choice; it’s an embrace that’s ready to envelop you in a world you never expected. Welcome to the warmth, welcome to the elegance, welcome to LGBTQ+ Staten Island!

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island
gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island
gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island

Highlights Of Moving To LGBTQ Staten Island

Staten Island might seem like the unassuming sibling of New York’s boroughs, but don’t be fooled. Behind its calm facade lies a community rich in diversity and a subtle but undeniable queer charm. While not flaunting its LGBTQ+ pride as openly as some neighbors, Staten Island’s appeal lies in its unique blend of the traditional with the modern, the urban with the suburban.

Here, the LGBTQ+ community thrives in pockets of warmth and acceptance, where establishments like Q Bar & Lounge offer a lively yet intimate space for socializing. In neighborhoods like St. George, you’ll discover a thriving arts scene, welcoming cafes, and an increasingly visible queer community.

Staten Island isn’t about being flashy; it’s about being authentic. It’s about a rich tapestry that weaves together the best of city living with a small-town feel, a place where you can enjoy Sunday brunch at the local hotspot, Bayou, known for its Southern charm and comfort food.

Plant your rainbow flag in Staten Island, and you’ll find yourself part of an engaged, beautifully diverse community. Whether you’re an art lover drawn to the Snug Harbor Cultural Center, or a nature enthusiast ready to explore the Greenbelt, Staten Island will captivate your queer heart.

But, dear reader, let’s take our time. Let’s saunter through the serenity and subtle whispers of queerness that make Staten Island an enchanting adventure. Allow us to guide you through the hidden gems and local favorites that make LGBTQ+ Staten Island not just a place to live, but a place to belong. Your adventure in Staten Island promises a delightful blend of the unexpected and the familiar, waiting to be discovered.

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island

Gastronomic Haven 

Staten Island boasts a diverse culinary landscape, with a wide range of restaurants and food choices, from Italian to Spanish to Sri Lankan cuisine. With more than a third of the population identifying as Italian, it’s no surprise that Italian-American food is a standout. From family-owned eateries to Michelin-starred establishments, the island offers everything from comfort food to exotic cuisine.

Thriving Night Scene 

While Manhattan is known for its never-ending nightlife, Staten Island offers a more relaxed alternative, with lounges and pubs to unwind. The island has an array of clubs and bars featuring live DJs, providing the perfect setting for a weekend out.

Staten Island has plenty to offer if you’re seeking more activities after sunset. And, if you’re looking for a more vibrant night scene, the other boroughs are just a short ferry ride away, with the Staten Island Ferry operating 24/7.

Attractions Are In Plenty

Attractions on Staten Island are diverse and captivating, providing a unique experience for anyone who visits. The Staten Island ferry is amongst the most famous attractions, offering breathtaking views of Manhattan, Ellis Island, and the Statue of Liberty. The ferry runs 24/7, allowing you to enjoy the scenery at any time of day.

Once you get off, you can stop by the nearby mall for shopping and entertainment. Staten Island, also known as the Borough of Parks, has covered you if you love outdoor activities with 170 different parks, including the largest park in New York City, Freshkills Park, which boasts diverse wildlife and native grasses.

During summer, you can relax at Staten Island Beach or stroll along the FDR boardwalk, where you’ll discover unique monuments showcasing the heritage and history of the island.

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island

Does Staten Island Embrace The LGBTQ Community?

Although Greenwich Village or Park Slope might not be what comes to mind when thinking about New York City’s LGBTQ+ cultural hotspots, Staten Island has a rich history of pride and adversity for the community. As early as the 1900s, members of the LGBTQ+ community have called Staten Island their home.

Despite significant progress, the Island still has a long way to go to become an inclusive space. For instance, local organizers have historically prevented gay, lesbian, and transgender groups from participating in the city’s local parade, even after the New York City St. Patrick’s Day parade in Manhattan lifted a two-decade ban on LGBTQ+ groups in 2014. 

In 2020, parade officials went even further and removed several well-known individuals, including a Republican City Council member and Miss Staten Island, from the parade due to perceived public statements supporting LGBTQ+ people. 

Despite these challenges, the LGBTQ+ community on Staten Island is thriving, with numerous organizations and events, including support groups, pride marches, and drag shows. It is a community with a rich and complex history that is still being written today.

Happy Queer Community
Shop Gay Underwear Sale Now At Queer In The World Shop

Is Staten Island An Expensive City To Move To?

Staten Island offers homes with larger square footage, spacious lots, and front driveways, which sets them apart from other boroughs and adds more value. Staten Island’s median home value is approximately $650k, which is more affordable than Manhattan’s exorbitant median home value of $1.5 million and Brooklyn’s median home value of $842k.

Even though Staten Island is more affordable, it still ranks as New York City’s second wealthiest borough, with a median household income of around $82,783, which means residents here earn more but pay less compared to other areas.

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island

The Best Gay Neighborhoods In Staten Island

While modern media may have you believing that the gayborhood is going the way of VHS tapes and flip phones, we’re here to proudly set the record straight – or should we say, queer? Gayborhoods across the USA aren’t fading; they’re flourishing, evolving, and redefining themselves, much like a Madonna reinvention.

These thriving spaces have transitioned from being a stereotypical ‘gay village’ – a Main Street serving predominantly LGBTQ+ clientele – into vibrant cultural archipelagos. They are glittering constellations of queer islands, united by sexuality, gender, and our fabulous straight allies. And just like episodes of ‘Queer as Folk’, cities often boast more than one!

Not every LGBTQ+ individual in Staten Island wants to live amidst the (relative) non-stop hustle and bustle of George, Tompkinsville, Clifton, and Stapleton—which is the island’s most urban area. It’s not all ‘Sex and the City’, after all. Thankfully, you’ve got options, much like choosing the right shade of lipstick for an unforgettable night out.

When deciding where to plant your roots in Staten Island, remember that some neighborhoods are closer to all the glitz and glam of queer events and activities. This insider knowledge means you’ll land right in the heart of a gay-friendly district that fits you like your favorite pair of skinny jeans.

Embark on your journey to a new home in one of the vibrant gay and LGBTQ+ inclusive gayborhoods in Staten Island. Each is as unique as a RuPaul runway look, offering a welcoming atmosphere and amenities that will soon have you saying, “Sashay, I stay!” Take your time to explore the myriad districts of Staten Island, and remember; this city extends its rainbow welcome mat to everyone, queer or not!

Ready to take a deep dive into the fabulous gay enclaves of Staten Island? Let’s get into it! Or, for a more detailed rundown of your best options, speak to a local LGBTQ+ real estate agent. They’ll ensure you find a place that’ll make even the Queer Eye’s Fab Five green with envy!

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island


If you think finding peace in New York City is impossible, you haven’t visited Huguenot. Tucked away on Staten Island’s south shore, this neighborhood is known for its modern, spacious family homes and lack of traffic problems compared to other parts of the city.

In addition to its peaceful atmosphere, Huguenot also boasts convenient access to beautiful beaches and the South Shore Country Club. Golf enthusiasts can even purchase a home right on the green to enjoy a park-like setting daily. It’s no wonder retirees and families with children are drawn to this safe and welcoming neighborhood.

The only downside to living in Huguenot is finding a place to park your car. However, public transportation options like the Huguenot station, which offers access to the MTA Staten Island Railway and buses and taxis, make getting around easy. If you’re looking for a serene oasis within the city, Huguenot might be the perfect place to call home.

Huguenot is a peaceful and affluent neighborhood on Staten Island’s south shore, characterized by modern family homes and a lack of commercial activity, resulting in less traffic congestion. The neighborhood’s residents enjoy easy access to beaches and the South Shore Country Club, which offers swimming, golfing, and tennis opportunities. 

Huguenot is also home to several top-rated public and private schools, making it one of the best neighborhoods for families with children.

Additionally, the area has several parks and recreational facilities, including the scenic Bloomingdale Park and the serene Lemon Creek Park. While parking can be challenging, public transportation options are readily available, including the Huguenot railway station and several bus routes.

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island

Todt Hill

A Lavish Haven Todt Hill is a prized gem of New York City, providing a serene retreat for sophisticated and affluent individuals. Its grand mansions, verdant flora, and tranquil atmosphere make it a tranquil haven. With an elevation of 390 feet above sea level, Todt Hill is the highest point on the Eastern Seaboard, apart from Maine, offering breathtaking ocean views. 

Families and retirees can relish the tranquility of the region and the nearby country club, with several large homes and a private school making it an excellent location for children. However, those who prefer a close-knit community might not find it in Todt Hill. With few sidewalks and residents living in their little paradises, socializing with neighbors can be challenging. 

The Staten Island Academy, a prestigious private school, is located in the heart of Todt Hill, and many families with school-aged children choose to make the area their home. Richmond County Country Club, one of the country’s oldest and most exclusive private golf clubs, is also located in Todt Hill.

It offers residents access to world-class golfing, swimming, and tennis facilities. At the same time, the neighborhood may lack a sense of community; its breathtaking ocean views and picturesque surroundings more than make up for it.

West New Brighton

West New Brighton is a petite neighborhood in terms of area, but its population density is twice the Staten Island average. It is home to many middle-class families and individuals residing in homes and apartment buildings built before 1939.

The area has an old-world charm, and its reputation as a crime hotspot has waned recently. West New Brighton also boasts the Staten Island Zoo, providing families with a fun leisure spot to enjoy their downtime. The neighborhood is home to a good combination of single-family homes, multi-unit buildings, and apartment complexes, catering to a broad range of middle-class families and individuals.

The neighborhood’s main commercial thoroughfare, Forest Avenue, features many shops, restaurants, and other businesses, making it a well-loved destination for locals and visitors alike. West New Brighton is also home to the Staten Island Zoo, a popular family-friendly attraction that houses over 1,100 animals worldwide.

The area has experienced a decline in crime rates in recent years, and its tree-lined streets, welcoming neighbors, and a strong sense of community make it a popular choice for those looking for a welcoming and affordable place to call home.

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island

LGBTQ+ Community Organizations In Staten Island

Wherever you decide to hang your glittering disco ball, it’s paramount that you become an advocate for LGBTQ+ organizations in any way you can. These stalwarts are our community’s equivalent of the valiant ‘Pose’ House Mothers, relentlessly reaching out and offering support to those in need. Remember, just as the cast of ‘The L Word’ proved, we are mightier when we unite, and we’ll all face moments akin to our own ‘Brokeback Mountain’ when an extra dose of love and understanding becomes essential.

Staten Island is proud to wave its rainbow flag high, thanks to a vibrant, diverse LGBTQ+ community much like Jodie Foster – not always in the spotlight but continually working behind the scenes to bolster the city’s embrace of all things queer.

Consequently, an array of LGBTQ+ resources has sprung up, poised to serve community members, allies, friends, and families. Think of these as the ‘Gentleman Jack’ of our community, subtly powerful and a beacon of joy when you need it. Feel encouraged to tap into these resources or consider lending your hand to ensure your newfound home continues to sashay forward with pride!

Plus, they provide the perfect backdrop to network, make connections, and discover your fabulous queer crew in Staten Island, ready to rule the city just like the ‘Drag Race’ queens do the runway!

The Staten Island LGBT Community Center

Staten Island LGBT Community Center, an initiative of Community Health Action of Staten Island, serves as a valuable resource for its LGBTQ+ community by providing a range of services and activities that promote their physical, mental, and emotional well-being. The center is supported by donations from various organizations and individuals, which helps them to achieve their goal of creating a more inclusive and just community.

The Center

The Center is another organization dedicated to serving the LGBTQ+ community in New York City. Since its founding in 1983, it has been a hub for the community, providing a welcoming space for individuals to connect, engage, and find support. Its mission is to empower members of the LGBTQ+ community and promote diversity, justice, and opportunity.

The Pride Center of Staten Island

The Pride Center of Staten Island is an organization that seeks to improve the well-being of the LGBTQ+ community in Staten Island. They aim to provide programs and services that cultivate community, advocate for LGBTQ+ interests, educate and empower individuals, and provide social support.

The Pride Center envisions a future where individuals of all sexual orientations, gender identities, races, and ethnicities feel a sense of belonging and are empowered to achieve their fullest potential, with support from allies who value and celebrate their uniqueness and interests.

Moving To LGBTQ Staten Island, New York? How To Find Your Perfect Gay Neighborhood!

LGBTQ-Owned Businesses In Staten Island

Embracing the radiant vibrancy of our queer community upon setting foot in your new locale, LGBT Staten Island, is not just essential—it’s profoundly empowering. It’s about curating an atmosphere where every queer soul can breathe freely, explore avidly, dine heartily, and connect deeply without an ounce of fear, and our LGBT businesses are the indefatigable champions leading this powerful charge.

Nurturing these brave endeavors, no matter where your home is pinned on the map, plays a cardinal role in the sustenance and flourishing of our queer community. Every time you funnel your resources into local ventures, you’re planting a seed of personal investment into the vibrant tapestry of your new city and community. Such seemingly tiny steps, when taken collectively, have the potency to create ripples of transformative change.

So, come, let’s explore some of the dazzling LGBTQ+-owned stars shining brightly in the cityscape of Staten Island. With every purchase you make, you’re amplifying their voice, endorsing their courage, and infusing your pink dollars with a sense of purpose and pride…


Zhe by Karyn Elizabeth is a store that offers lingerie for the TGNC community in Staten Island. The owner, Karyn, is a fierce advocate for the transgender community and started the business to address the fit and function needs of the community.

The brand focuses on addressing the fit and function needs of the TGNC community to empower trans women through all phases of their transition. Zhe is dedicated to creating undergarments that fit well and make the wearer feel confident and comfortable in their body.

Karyn Elizabeth started Zhe after following her passion for design and taking Continuing Education classes at Parsons School of Design. What began as a hobby turned into a mission to create undergarments catering to the TGNC community’s specific needs.


Maizal is a beacon of Fine Mexican Cuisine on Staten Island, setting it apart from the typical Mexican restaurants in New York. Inspired by the eclectic culinary landscape of Mexico City’s most vibrant neighborhoods, Maizal strives to create a dining experience that surpasses expectations.

With a menu that dares to be different, Maizal’s offerings not only tantalize taste buds but also push the boundaries of traditional Mexican cuisine with daring and inventive recipes. The presentation of each dish is a work of art, reflecting the captivating aesthetics found in Mexico City’s most prestigious districts.

Shop LGBTQ+ Pride Designs @

Final Thoughts On Moving To LGBTQ Staten Island

Staten Island, with its blend of urban energy and suburban tranquility, is more than just a borough—it’s a sanctuary. Its shores, not just sandy beaches but gateways to peaceful living, offer a refreshing contrast to Manhattan’s bustle. From the charming neighborhoods like Tompkinsville to the cultural delights at the St. George Theatre, Staten Island welcomes you with a serene embrace.

Are you yearning for a place where you can be yourself, where the rent is within reach and the dream of homeownership is alive? If the answer is a resounding yes, Staten Island may just be the glittering gem you’ve been searching for.

In LGBT Staten Island, you don’t just find a home, you find a community. Let’s embark on this exciting journey together and explore the gay-friendly pockets, vibrant events like Staten Island PrideFest, and welcoming spaces like the Pride Center of Staten Island.

Embrace Staten Island’s gentle charm, pledge your love to its diverse tapestry, and dive into its thriving queer community. Let this advice guide you, like a beacon lighting up the path to where your passions and ideals find harmony.

Planting roots in LGBT Staten Island won’t just be smooth; it’ll be like a well-choreographed dance that leaves you feeling both exhilarated and at home. Believe us, this new beginning is more than promising—it’s positively sparkling, and it awaits your fabulous touch. So, what are you waiting for, darling? Staten Island is calling, and it’s ready to embrace you in all your queer glory.

gay Staten Island - Staten Island gayborhood - lgbtq Staten Island - moving to lgbtq Staten Island

Finding Gay Realtors In Staten Island

Might you question the significance of a realtor’s sexual orientation when you’re on the quest for your dream home? This might strike you as peculiar initially, but allow me to elucidate the myriad reasons why reaching out to a gay realtor in Staten Island could be your ticket to that perfect abode.

Isn’t it reasonable to seek fair, equitable, and honest representation from someone who deeply grasps the unique aspirations and requirements of the queer community, especially while navigating one of life’s most significant transactions?

After all, it’s unfortunate that a considerable segment of our society (up to one-third of Americans) still harbor the misguided belief that our community isn’t worthy of protection and respect in fundamental areas of life, such as housing, employment, adoption, and beyond.

Consequently, it’s not shocking to hear of LGBT individuals who engage with mainstream realtors recounting tales of discomfort, avoidable hurdles, lackluster representation, or even hostility and overt derision.

Everyone is entitled to a joyful, hassle-free experience when buying or selling a home and to have representation that sees them for who they truly are. This is why we champion the idea of engaging a gay realtor to aid you in uncovering the perfect sanctuary you can call home.

Staten Island gay realtor * gay real estate in Staten Island * lgbt realtors in Staten Island * lgbt friendly real estate agents near me

LGBTQ realtors offer a unique edge when it comes to searching for a home—they’re not only knowledgeable about the diverse neighborhoods within their area, but they have an innate understanding of which might align seamlessly with your unique needs.

It doesn’t imply that heterosexual realtors lack proficiency; they haven’t had to confront many of the challenges that the LGBT community frequently encounters. Gay realtors delve deeply into the heart of the neighborhoods where they operate, ensuring their clients’ safety takes precedence over how vibrant, trendy, or on-the-rise an area might be (or is perceived to be).

Not too long ago, finding professional, LGBT-friendly real estate agents in Staten Island was no easy feat—especially if you were moving from another state and lacked a local connection for referrals. Today, however, that’s a concern of the past. A curated list of gay, lesbian, and gay-friendly agents in Staten Island is available to shoulder the burden of your search.

All you need to do is visit the designated webpage, and voilà!—a comprehensive, cost-free directory of gay, lesbian, and gay-friendly agents ready to aid your relocation will be at your fingertips.

Also included is a wealth of additional resources, like LGBT+friendly schools, shopping venues, storage companies, tradespeople, and more. Peruse the profiles of the LGBT real estate agents, and choose the one that feels just right for you. It’s paramount to connect with someone who will stand by you, offering unwavering support to you and your family during this exhilarating life event.

And here’s the cherry on top: there’s no hidden agenda, charge, or obligation. Your journey to a new home begins here, championed by the expertise and empathy of a realtor who truly understands your needs.

Staten Island gay realtor * gay real estate in Staten Island * lgbt realtors in Staten Island * lgbt friendly real estate agents near me
gay friendly realtors near me