Lesbian film critic Sofia De Vera merges academic expertise with a heartfelt focus on queer cinema, advocating for meaningful LGBTQIA+ narratives through 15 years of reflective and celebratory film criticism.
In a cinematic landscape traditionally dominated by monogamous love stories, a refreshing wave of Polyamorous movies is emerging, breaking the mold and exploring the intricate dynamics of polyamorous relationships.
As societal norms evolve and discussions about diverse forms of relationships gain momentum, these films are at the forefront, embracing the challenge of portraying love in its multifaceted and non-traditional forms. They offer audiences a glimpse into the complexities, joys, and challenges of polyamory, broadening the portrayal of love on the silver screen.
The result? A collection of thought-provoking and emotionally resonant films that explore the complexities, joys, and challenges of polyamorous relationships. From soul-stirring dramas to lighthearted comedies, these cinematic creations not only entertain but also serve as mirrors reflecting the diverse ways in which humans experience and navigate the realm of love.
In this article, we embark on a journey through the best polyamorous movies, unpacking their narratives, character dynamics, and the larger cultural significance they hold in fostering conversations about love beyond boundaries. So, grab your popcorn and an open heart as we delve into the captivating world of cinema that celebrates the many facets of human connections.
Wondering where to watch? It depends on where you live in the world and which streaming services you have. We link to the streaming service we watch on in each case - be it Netflix, Amazon Prime, Apply TV+, or elsewhere.
You can get one month free of Amazon Pride (or a 6-month trial for students) of Amazon Prime and also get immediate access to FREE Two Day shipping, Amazon Video, and Music. While you won't be charged for your free trial, you'll be upgraded to a paid membership plan automatically at the end of the trial period - though if you have already binged all these, you could just cancel before the trial ends.
Apple TV+ also has a one-week trial, and Hulu has a one-month trial (which can be bundled with Disney!). Another option might be using a VPN to access Netflix titles locked to other regions. Netflix is now available in more than 190 countries worldwide and each country has a different library and availability. US Netflix is (understandably) one of the best.
While we wish everything could just be in one place - for now, it seems these are the best streaming platforms to watch on.
In this article we will cover...
The Dreamers (2003)
The Dreamers, a film directed by Bernardo Bertolucci, stands as a captivating exploration of youth, culture, and rebellion. Bertolucci, acclaimed for his distinctive cinematic style and visionary storytelling, had already made a name for himself with films like Last Tango in Paris and The Last Emperor.
Set against the backdrop of the tumultuous 1968 Parisian student protests, the film follows the lives of three young cinephiles: Matthew, Isabelle, and Theo. The trio’s paths intertwine as they share their love for cinema, forming a unique bond that transcends societal norms. As the protests escalate, the characters’ relationships evolve, leading to intense emotional discoveries that question their beliefs and desires.
Paris, an iconic city known for its rich history and artistic heritage, becomes an integral element of the narrative. Bertolucci skillfully captures the city’s essence, using its architecture, streets, and landmarks to mirror the characters’ journey of self-discovery. The film’s evocative portrayal of Paris immerses viewers in the era’s cultural and political upheavals, enhancing the authenticity of the story.
Intriguingly depicting the intimacy of relationships and the impact of socio-political change, The Dreamers offers a vivid window into a pivotal moment in history. Whether drawn to its narrative depth, artistic prowess, or historical backdrop, viewers are bound to find themselves captivated by this cinematic gem. For those seeking a film that challenges conventions and prompts introspection, The Dreamers is a must-watch that encapsulates the beauty of youthful rebellion and the complexities of human experience.
Dedication (2007)
Dedication is a film directed by Justin Theroux, marking his directorial debut. Prior to his foray into directing, Theroux was renowned for his acting career, featuring in both television and film. His shift to the director’s chair showcased his multifaceted talent.
The film follows the story of Henry Roth (Billy Crudup), a misanthropic and eccentric children’s book author who is compelled to collaborate with illustrator Lucy Reilly (Mandy Moore) after his original illustrator and friend passes away. The narrative unravels through their tumultuous partnership, as their conflicting personalities clash while navigating the challenges of creativity, personal demons, and burgeoning affection.
Set against the backdrop of picturesque landscapes, Dedication primarily takes place in a small New England town. The setting is a seamless complement to the characters’ emotional arcs, reflecting their isolation and emotional struggles. The town’s quaint charm juxtaposes the protagonists’ inner turmoils, underscoring the emotional depth of the narrative.
Dedication is a must-watch for its compelling narrative, superb performances, and evocative depiction of the human experience. Theroux’s directorial debut showcases his ability to delve into complex emotions and relationships, while the talented cast breathes life into the characters.
With a perfect blend of drama, humor, and heart, the film engages the audience on multiple levels. Whether you’re a fan of romantic dramas or simply looking for a thought-provoking film, Dedication offers a unique and captivating experience that lingers long after the credits roll.
Bandits (1997)
Bandits is a film directed by Katja von Garnier, a German filmmaker known for her unique storytelling style and focus on strong female characters. Von Garnier’s career has been marked by her ability to blend emotion with visual aesthetics, as evident in her earlier works such as Making Up! and Iron Jawed Angels.
The film Bandits follows the journey of four young women in their 20s who form an all-female rock band named Bandits after escaping from a mental institution. The plot revolves around their pursuit of freedom and self-discovery while navigating the challenges of an unyielding society. With an edgy mix of drama, comedy, and music, the film delves into themes of friendship, rebellion, and the quest for identity.
Set against the backdrop of Berlin, the film vividly captures the city’s gritty and vibrant atmosphere. The urban landscape serves as a metaphor for the characters’ journey – a place of both opportunity and adversity. The portrayal of Berlin is a central aspect of the movie, depicting it as a city of contradictions and possibilities that mirror the Bandits’ own transformation.
If you’re looking for a film that combines rebellious spirit with a strong sense of camaraderie, Bandits is a must-watch. Katja von Garnier’s direction brings out the raw emotions of the characters, and the engaging plot keeps you hooked from start to finish.
Whether you’re drawn to unconventional stories, a fan of music-themed films, or simply appreciate films that explore the complexities of female friendships, Bandits offers a cinematic experience that is both entertaining and thought-provoking.
Nina Forever (2015)
Nina Forever is a British romantic-horror film directed by brothers Ben and Chris Blaine, marking their debut as feature film directors. The Blaine brothers’ background in short films and television gave them a unique perspective on blending genres, a talent that is evident in this film.
The film’s plot centers around the unconventional love story of Rob (Cian Barry), a grieving supermarket employee haunted by his deceased girlfriend Nina (Fiona O’Shaughnessy), and his new co-worker, Holly (Abigail Hardingham). As Rob and Holly’s budding romance becomes entangled with Nina’s lingering presence, the film delves into themes of grief, obsession, and the complexities of human relationships.
Set in an ordinary British town, Nina Forever portrays the familiar surroundings with an unsettling twist. The mundane grocery store and the characters’ everyday lives serve as a stark contrast to the supernatural elements that infiltrate their world. This setting serves as a metaphor for the characters’ emotional states, highlighting the collision between the banality of life and the lingering specter of death.
Nina Forever challenges traditional genre boundaries and offers a fresh take on themes of love and loss. With its innovative storytelling, compelling characters, and unexpected twists, the film captivates viewers from start to finish. If you’re a fan of unconventional love stories that explore the complexities of human emotions in unexpected ways, Nina Forever is a must-watch.
Chasing Amy (1997)
Chasing Amy is a thought-provoking romantic comedy-drama directed by Kevin Smith, known for his distinctive approach to filmmaking and storytelling. Smith gained recognition with his debut film Clerks (1994), characterized by its low-budget production and witty dialogue. In Chasing Amy, Smith takes a step further, delving into complex relationships and issues of identity.
The film follows the story of Holden McNeil (Ben Affleck), a comic book artist, and his best friend Banky Edwards (Jason Lee). Set in New Jersey, the narrative takes an unexpected turn when Holden falls for Alyssa Jones (Joey Lauren Adams), a fellow comic book artist. However, Alyssa’s past complicates their budding romance, as she is openly gay and has a history of relationships with women.
Smith skillfully navigates the emotional turmoil of Holden, who struggles to reconcile his feelings for Alyssa with her sexual orientation. The film’s setting, New Jersey, serves as a backdrop that influences the characters’ attitudes and perspectives. It portrays the suburban landscape as a place where personal relationships are influenced by societal norms and personal biases.
Viewers are encouraged to watch Chasing Amy for its engaging storyline, genuine performances, and Smith’s trademark dialogue. The director’s ability to tackle sensitive subjects with wit and authenticity sets this film apart. It’s a reminder that love is not always straightforward and that personal growth often requires introspection and the willingness to challenge one’s preconceptions.
Professor Marston and the Wonder Women (2017)
Professor Marston and the Wonder Women is a biographical drama directed by Angela Robinson. Robinson, known for her work in television and film, brings her unique vision to this captivating narrative. The film delves into the unconventional and intriguing life of Dr. William Moulton Marston, a Harvard psychologist, and the creation of the iconic Wonder Woman character.
Set in the 1920s and 1930s, the plot unravels the complex relationship between Dr. Marston (Luke Evans) and his wife Elizabeth Marston (Rebecca Hall), along with their mutual lover Olive Byrne (Bella Heathcote). Their polyamorous dynamic, influenced by their progressive beliefs, significantly contributes to the conceptualization of Wonder Woman, a symbol of strength and empowerment.
The film is primarily set in the intellectual and societal backdrop of Harvard University and suburban America. The settings not only provide historical context but also act as reflective spaces for the characters’ evolving ideas and relationships. The juxtaposition of academic rigidity and personal exploration enhances the film’s thematic depth.
Professor Marston and the Wonder Women portrays these characters against the norms of their time, showcasing their courage to challenge societal conventions. The film’s narrative offers insight into the complexities of human connections, personal aspirations, and the societal forces that shape them. Ultimately, the movie provides a thought-provoking experience that will linger in the minds of its audience, inspiring discussions on feminism, love, and individuality.
Shortbus (2006)
Shortbus is a film directed by John Cameron Mitchell, known for his unique approach to storytelling and exploration of complex themes. Mitchell’s career has been marked by his ability to delve into unconventional narratives and challenge societal norms, as seen in his earlier work, Hedwig and the Angry Inch.
The film follows the lives of several interconnected characters in New York City, who are all seeking emotional, sexual, and personal fulfillment. Set against the backdrop of post-9/11 New York, Shortbus intricately weaves together the stories of a sex therapist, a dominatrix, a gay couple, and other diverse individuals. These characters find solace and connection in an underground salon called Shortbus, where they engage in candid and explicit conversations about their desires and struggles.
New York City itself becomes a character in the film, portrayed as a vibrant and diverse metropolis that mirrors the complexity of its inhabitants. Mitchell captures the city’s energy and resilience, while also acknowledging its vulnerabilities in the wake of tragedy. The film’s portrayal of New York is raw and unfiltered, embracing both its beauty and its flaws.
Shortbus’s unique storytelling, combined with its authentic portrayal of characters and their struggles, offers a profound glimpse into the complexities of human relationships. By immersing viewers in a world that embraces the full spectrum of emotions and desires, Shortbus encourages us to confront our own insecurities and desires while celebrating the beauty of genuine human connection.
We Don’t Live Here Anymore (2004)
We Don’t Live Here Anymore is a poignant drama directed by John Curran, an Australian filmmaker known for his adept exploration of complex emotions and relationships. Curran’s directorial career has been marked by his ability to delve into the intricacies of human connections, often revealing the fragility and rawness beneath the surface.
Set in a small town in New England, the film follows the lives of two couples whose intertwined relationships unravel over a period of time. The narrative revolves around Jack (Mark Ruffalo) and Terry (Laura Dern), and Hank (Peter Krause) and Edith (Naomi Watts), who find themselves entangled in a web of infidelity, emotional turmoil, and the consequences of their actions.
We Don’t Live Here Anymore is a poignant exploration of human fallibility and the complexities of desire, resentment, and betrayal. The director’s skilled craftsmanship allows the audience to intimately experience the characters’ emotions, providing a raw and unflinching portrayal of their inner turmoil. With its honest portrayal of flawed characters and its exploration of the fragility of human connections, We Don’t Live Here Anymore is a cinematic experience that lingers in the mind long after the credits roll.
Savage Grace (2007)
Savage Grace is a compelling drama directed by Tom Kalin, an accomplished filmmaker known for his distinctive approach to storytelling and visual aesthetics. Kalin’s career has been marked by a penchant for delving into complex characters and relationships, often exploring the human psyche’s darker corners.
The film is based on the true story of the Baekeland family, focusing on the tumultuous relationship between Barbara Daly Baekeland (played by Julianne Moore) and her son Antony (played by Eddie Redmayne). The narrative unfolds against the backdrop of high society in the 1940s and 50s, tracing the family’s journey from New York to Paris and eventually to the Mediterranean coast.
Savage Grace delves into the psychological intricacies of the Baekeland family, exposing the effects of wealth, privilege, and family dynamics on their lives. As the story navigates the world of socialites, artists, and the jet-set elite, it offers a stark portrayal of the veneer of glamour and sophistication masking deeper emotional turmoil.
Savage Grace is a thought-provoking cinematic experience that invites audiences to contemplate the intricate interplay of privilege, desire, and the human psyche within the realm of a visually captivating narrative.
The One I Love (2014)
The One I Love is a film directed by Charlie McDowell, marking his directorial debut. McDowell, son of actors Malcolm McDowell and Mary Steenburgen, embarked on his filmmaking career with this intriguing and unconventional work. His ability to navigate complex emotional landscapes and blend them with a touch of surrealism is evident in this thought-provoking movie.
The film centers on Ethan (Mark Duplass) and Sophie (Elisabeth Moss), a couple whose marriage is on the rocks. Seeking to mend their relationship, they embark on a weekend retreat at a picturesque country house. However, their idyllic getaway takes an uncanny twist when they discover that the property harbors an inexplicable anomaly.
As they venture into a guest house, they find alternate versions of themselves, seemingly embodying their best traits and desires. This sets the stage for a mind-bending exploration of identity, relationships, and the complexities of love.
The One I Love is an engrossing cinematic experience that challenges conventions and leaves audiences pondering its implications. With its inventive premise and compelling performances by Duplass and Moss, the film serves as a captivating exploration of the human psyche and the multifaceted nature of love. It’s a narrative that blurs the lines between reality and illusion, taking viewers on an introspective journey that lingers long after the credits roll.
For those seeking a film that ventures beyond the conventional boundaries of storytelling, The One I Love offers a fresh perspective on relationships and the intricacies that define them. McDowell’s directorial prowess, coupled with the film’s surreal ambiance, makes it a must-watch for those who appreciate thought-provoking cinema that challenges the mind and tugs at the heartstrings.
Four Lovers (2010)
Four Lovers is a French romantic drama film directed by Antony Cordier. Cordier, known for his exploration of human relationships and desires, showcases his directorial finesse in this captivating piece. Having previously worked on films like Cold Showers (2005) and Happy Few (2010), Cordier continues his thematic exploration of complex interpersonal dynamics.
The film revolves around the lives of two couples, Rachel and Franck, and Vincent and Teri. Tired of their routine marital lives, the two couples decide to venture into uncharted territory by embarking on a shared journey of sexual experimentation and partner swapping. As they delve into their desires and test the boundaries of their relationships, the foursome becomes entangled in a web of emotions, jealousy, and self-discovery. The plot adeptly navigates the fine line between passion and emotional turmoil, while
Four Lovers offers a thought-provoking cinematic experience. Its exploration of unconventional relationships and intimate desires lends a refreshing perspective on the intricacies of human connections. Cordier’s direction seamlessly weaves together an engaging narrative with evocative visuals, making the film a captivating watch for those intrigued by the complexities of human emotions and relationships.
If you’re seeking a film that delves into the depths of desire, jealousy, and self-discovery, Four Lovers comes highly recommended. It provides an unflinching gaze into the human psyche while skillfully portraying the beautiful yet tumultuous landscape of the human heart.
Y Tu Mamá También (2001)
Y Tu Mamá También, directed by Alfonso Cuarón, is a coming-of-age Mexican film. Cuarón, known for his diverse directorial achievements including Gravity and Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, brings his unique storytelling prowess to this captivating film.
The plot revolves around two teenage friends, Julio and Tenoch, portrayed by Gael García Bernal and Diego Luna, respectively. The boys embark on a road trip with Luisa, a woman in her late twenties played by Maribel Verdú.
The journey starts as a simple adventure, but quickly morphs into a life-altering experience, marked by self-discovery, burgeoning sexuality, and complex relationships. Against the backdrop of Mexico’s diverse landscapes, the film delves into themes of friendship, desire, and the transient nature of existence.
Set against the backdrop of Mexico‘s socio-political landscape, Y Tu Mamá También paints an unfiltered picture of the country’s realities. The film takes viewers on a visual tour through the Mexican countryside, juxtaposing its breathtaking beauty with its deep-rooted social issues. This visual narration serves as a metaphor for the characters’ personal journeys as they grapple with their own insecurities and desires.
Y Tu Mamá También is a must-watch for several reasons. Cuarón’s deft direction is complemented by the outstanding performances of the lead actors, who successfully navigate the emotional complexities of their characters. By delving into the youthful psyche and the larger social fabric, the film offers a multidimensional experience that resonates universally.
Whether one is drawn to its exploration of the human psyche, its evocative setting, or its poignant themes, Y Tu Mamá También stands as an engaging cinematic work that continues to captivate audiences, inviting them to embark on a transformative journey alongside its characters.